Member-only story

Nationalism, Chauvinism, and Racism: Reflections in European Musical Thought and Practice

Neal Ward

·6.2k Followers· Follow

Published in Nationalism Chauvinism And Racism As Reflected In European Musical Thought And In Compositions From The Interwar Period (Eastern European Studies In Musicology 14)

5 min read

636 View Claps

33 Respond

Save

Listen

Music, a universal language that transcends boundaries, has often been intertwined with nationalism, chauvinism, and racism throughout history. The 19th century witnessed a surge in nationalist sentiments across Europe, which influenced various aspects of society, including music. This article explores the complex relationship between these ideologies and European musical thought and practice during this pivotal era.

Nationalism and Music

Nationalism, a belief in the superiority of one's nation and its culture, played a significant role in shaping musical compositions and performances. Composers sought to incorporate folk melodies, rhythms, and harmonies into their works, aiming to evoke a sense of national identity and pride. Italian composers like Giuseppe Verdi and Gioachino Rossini celebrated the Italian Risorgimento with operas that glorified the struggle for national unity. In Germany, Richard Wagner used myth and folklore to create a distinct German musical style that appealed to nationalist sentiments.

Nationalism, Chauvinism and Racism as Reflected in European Musical Thought and in Compositions from the Interwar Period (Eastern European Studies in Musicology Book 14)

by Georgia Witkin

4 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	611 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	259 pages

Chauvinism and Musical Exclusivity

Chauvinism, an extreme form of nationalism that promotes the superiority of one's own nation over all others, also manifested in music. Composers and musicians often expressed disdain for music from other countries, dismissing it as inferior or uncivilized. The German composer Richard Strauss famously denounced French music as "decadent" and lacking in depth. This chauvinistic attitude created divisions and hindered the appreciation of musical diversity.

Racism and Musical Prejudice

Racism, the belief that one race is superior to others, also found expression in European music. Many composers and performers held racist views and excluded non-European musicians from their ranks. In the United States, Black musicians faced systemic barriers and discrimination in the classical music world. Scholars like Philip Bohlman have documented the exclusionary practices and racist ideologies that prevented Black musicians from achieving recognition and opportunities in mainstream classical music.

Manifestations in Performance and Composition

The ideologies of nationalism, chauvinism, and racism were not merely abstract concepts but had tangible implications for musical performance and composition. Concert programs often featured works by composers from the host nation, while foreign compositions were often marginalized. The selection of musicians for orchestras and opera companies was also influenced by nationalist and racist biases.

Furthermore, composers incorporated elements of folk music and national anthems into their compositions to evoke a sense of national unity and pride. They also adopted musical styles and techniques associated with specific ethnic groups, often exoticizing and stereotyping non-European cultures.

Challenging Ideologies

Despite the prevalence of nationalist, chauvinist, and racist ideologies in European music, there were also dissenting voices. Some composers and musicians actively challenged these ideas and promoted musical inclusivity. Ludwig van Beethoven's Ninth Symphony, with its "Ode to Joy" chorus, became a symbol of universal brotherhood and unity. The Hungarian composer Béla Bartók embraced and celebrated the musical traditions of different cultures, including Romanian, Slovak, and Turkish folk music.

Contemporary Relevance

The legacy of nationalism, chauvinism, and racism in European music continues to resonate in contemporary times. While overt expressions of these ideologies have diminished, subtle forms of exclusion and prejudice still exist in the classical music world. Organizations and initiatives aimed at promoting diversity and inclusion in music have made significant progress, but more work is needed to address systemic barriers and create a truly inclusive and equitable musical landscape.

The relationship between nationalism, chauvinism, racism, and European musical thought and practice is a complex and multifaceted one. These ideologies have influenced musical compositions, performances, and the treatment of musicians from different backgrounds. While nationalism can foster a sense of community and pride, it can also lead to exclusion and division. Chauvinism and racism have no place in music or any other realm of human endeavor. By recognizing and confronting these ideologies, we can create a more inclusive and diverse musical landscape that celebrates the richness and beauty of all cultures.

Alt Attributes

* Nationalism: Flag of the nation waving in the wind * Chauvinism: Groups of musicians from different countries playing music together * Racism: Musicians of different ethnicities performing on stage * European Musical Thought: Sheet music with notes and symbols * Influence on Composition: Composer writing music inspired by folk melodies * Manifestations in Performance: Orchestra playing a national anthem * Challenging Ideologies: Conductor leading a diverse ensemble * Contemporary Relevance: Musicians from different backgrounds collaborating on a musical project * Inclusivity and Equity: Musicians of all races, genders, and backgrounds performing together

Nationalism, Chauvinism and Racism as Reflected in European Musical Thought and in Compositions from the Interwar Period (Eastern European Studies in Musicology Book 14)

by Georgia Witkin

4 out of 5